HireBest Blog

Beyond the Gut Feel: Key Lessons from Craig della Penna’s SHRM 2026 Presentation on AI and Structured Hiring

Written by Megan Petrola | Jul 22, 2026 4:41:25 PM

Can artificial intelligence improve hiring outcomes without replacing human judgment?

That was the central question explored by Craig della Penna, Founder of Aesop Partners and creator of the HireBest® methodology, during his sold-out SHRM 2026 presentation,"Beyond the Gut Feel: How AI-Powered Structured Interviews Are Transforming Hiring Outcomes."

The answer is clear:

The future of hiring isn't AI versus humans. It's AI enhancing human decision-making.

As organizations struggle with turnover, hiring mistakes, and inconsistent interview practices, leaders are searching for better ways to identify and select top talent. Our message at SHRM was simple: hiring outcomes improve dramatically when organizations combine structured interviewing with AI-enabled tools that reduce friction, increase consistency, and improve decision quality.
 

Why So Many Hiring Decisions Fail

82% of new hires do not achieve the level of success organizations hope for, and nearly half leave within 18 months (Leadership IQ study).

The problem is not necessarily a lack of talent. It's a lack of process.

Most hiring failures can be traced back to three root causes:

  1. Organizations haven't clearly defined what success looks like before recruiting begins.
  2. Interviews generate inconsistent and difficult-to-compare data.
  3. Bias and intuition often outweigh objective evidence during decision-making.
When hiring depends primarily on instinct, even experienced leaders can make costly mistakes.
 

The First Step: Define Success Before You Interview

One of the major themes of the SHRM session was the importance of role clarity.

Many organizations begin recruiting with a job description but lack a shared understanding of what successful performance actually looks like. Effective hiring begins by identifying the handful of critical outcomes a person must deliver in the role—not simply a list of responsibilities.

The Cipher® framework was designed to help leaders define those outcomes before meeting a single candidate. By focusing on measurable deliverables, hiring teams can align expectations and evaluate talent more objectively.
 
At Aesop Partners, we've found that clarity before the interview process is one of the most significant predictors of hiring success.
 

How AI Removes Friction from Structured Hiring

If structured interviews are proven to be more effective, why aren't more organizations using them consistently?

The challenge isn't a lack of knowledge. The challenge is adoption.

Hiring managers frequently understand the value of structured interviewing, but many revert to conversational, intuition-driven interviews because traditional structured processes are viewed as cumbersome.

This is where the proliferation of higher-quality AI tools have changed the game for recruiting, and structured interviewing in particular. AI can help:

  • Define role-specific success criteria.
  • Generate targeted interview questions (based on the role, NOT biased for each candidate).
  • Identify potential gaps between candidate experience and role requirements.
  • Summarize interview conversations.
  • Assist with candidate evaluation.
  • Surface potential bias and compliance concerns
The result is a process that is easier to follow, creates more consistent data, and allows interviewers to focus on meaningful conversations rather than administrative tasks.
 

AI Should Support Decisions Not Make Them

A critical distinction is that AI is a tool, not a decision-maker.

Organizations should never outsource judgment, leadership, or accountability. Instead, AI should provide better information so leaders can make better decisions.

AI can help create structure, highlight gaps, and improve consistency, but human leaders remain responsible for selecting the right person for the role.

The goal is not automation. The goal is better decisions.

The Business Impact of Structured Hiring

Organizations that successfully implement structured hiring can experience benefits beyond recruiting:

  • Higher-quality hires.
  • Faster employee ramp-up.
  • Lower attrition.
  • Improved organizational performance.
  • Greater confidence in hiring decisions

When hiring teams consistently evaluate candidates against clearly defined success criteria, organizations create a repeatable process that improves over time.

Hiring becomes less dependent on individual interview styles and more focused on evidence.

The Future of Hiring Is Human + AI

One of the most resonant ideas from the SHRM 2026 conference, in both Craig's session and in numerous others, was that technology should strengthen not replace the human side of hiring.

AI can help organizations create structure, gather better data, reduce administrative burden, and improve consistency. Human leaders still provide judgment, context, relationship-building, and strategic thinking.

As Craig concluded during his presentation:
 
"When structured interviewing is combined with AI support, hiring becomes a system that improves itself over time."
 
For organizations looking to improve talent outcomes, reduce costly hiring mistakes, and build stronger teams, that future is already here.
 

About Aesop Partners and HireBest®

Aesop Partners helps boards, CEOs, private equity firms, and leadership teams make better talent decisions through structured assessment, leadership advisory services, and the HireBest® methodology. The Cipher® framework provides a practical, evidence-based approach to defining success, evaluating candidates, and improving hiring outcomes.

 
View full post